Facebook Gives Hate Speech a Pass


Senior -Planet-Ashton-Applewhite“This Chair Rocks” is a blog by Ashton Applewhite. Read more on her blog by clicking here and check out  Ashton’s other blog, Yo, Is This Ageist?  Recently on “This Chair Rocks,” Ashton wrote about ageism on Facebook.

Does “hate speech” sound strong? One Facebook group description stated that anyone “over the age of 69 should immediately face a firing squad.” It wasn’t the only group to reach for a gun. Others recommended banning older people from activities like driving or shopping.

These were among the 84 public English-language Facebook groups oriented towards old age and identified by a search engine using 75 terms, including “old,” “aged,” “elderly,” “retired,” “experienced,” “senile,” and “decrepit.” Combined, the groups have roughly 25,000 members.

Published in The Gerontologist online,  this was the first study of age stereotypes on social-networking sites. The results are pretty appalling. Descriptions of every group (except one devoted to Gandalf) focused on negative stereotypes. According to the study, “74% excoriated older individuals, 27% infantilized them, and 37% advocated banning them from public activities.” Most of the creators were between the ages of 20 and 29; none was over 60. In other words, youngers created these groups for the express purpose of denigrating their future selves.

Here’s the kicker: Facebook’s Community Standards forbids hate speech that mentions race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, sex, gender, sexual orientation, disability and disease – but not age.

In response to the study, Facebook spokesperson Andrew Noyes said that “direct statements of hate against particular communities” violate Facebook policy “and are removed when reported to us. However, groups that express an opinion on a state, institution or set of beliefs, even if that opinion is outrageous or offensive to some, do not by themselves violate our policies.” Huh? Unless age is not a “state”- different from being, say, queer or fat or Canadian – the statement contradicts itself. Lead researcher Becca Levy of Yale University, said her team reported 10 Facebook groups as being offensive. Eight of the groups remained in operation nearly a year later.

Facebook discriminates. Like the culture at large, the massive social network has yet to acknowledge that ageist comments are no more acceptable than racist or sexist ones.

Is Facebook’s refusal to ban ageist material discriminatory? If so, how should users of the social network respond? Stop using Facebook and encourage our friends to do the same? Organize a letter-writing campaign? Thoughts anyone? Please share your opinion in the comments box below.


2 responses to “Facebook Gives Hate Speech a Pass

  1. Finally…! I found someone who agrees with me and has noticed age discrimination toward the ‘elderly’…! I’ll be 65 in November and would assume that’s why I’ve become aware of such blatant age discrimination. It started with TV ads that portrayed older people in ridiculous light….clueless,confused,crotchety and just plain laughable. I commented to my husband that they’re would be such an outrage if minorities,handicapped or other segments of our society were so belittled…! Granted, some situations I can relate to but do they have to be presented this way ? Facebook is one of the worst places for this despicable portrayal..jokes,pictures,inuendo’s, etc. making fun of the older person. I don’t know what the solution is nor do I have any idea’s on how to stop this discrimination, just wanted to make others aware of what I’ve noticed.

Leave a Reply

Senior Planet is an open forum and offers articles for information only. We welcome comments from readers, but can’t be a go-between for readers who wish to contact each other via email for any reason. Since it is impossible to vet every commenter, Senior Planet’s policy is not to publish or share commenters’ emails for any reason, even if requested.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *